Reviews and Critiques

A Masterpiece by Matt Roberts

The book Number the Stars is a wonderful masterpiece written by Lois Lowry in 1988.  After you read this book, a fantastically told historical fiction on World War II, you will think it is a great story.  “According to Lowery, the Danish people were the only entire nation of people in the world who heard the splash and the cry and did not… turn away from the disaster.” Number the Stars was published by Bantam Doubleday Dell Publishing. This Newberry award winner, which demonstrates friendship and courage from the characters in it, is a must read. This story takes place in Copenhagen, Denmark.  The Germans have taken over. Although the Nazi regime during World War II had taken all of their resources, the people of Denmark were not giving up easily.  Rebelling, a clan of youths tries to secretly resist the German demands. Secretly these people help the Jews escape, while Germans are chasing after them.

There are many characters in this story: Mr. Johansen, Mrs. Johansen, Lise Johansen, Mr. Rosen, Mrs. Rosen, Mr. Hirsch, Mrs. Hirsch, Mrs. Hirsch’s son, Peter Neilsen, Uncle Henrik, King Christian X, German soldiers, and Thor the cat.  The three main characters are Kirsti Johansen, who is a young brat with a mouth of a bullhorn, Ellen Rosen, and most importantly, Annemarie Johansen. Ruthlessly, the Germans had ordered that all the Jews be taken to concentration camps. Having the Johansens as friends and neighbors, the Rosens, being Jewish, would have to be protected. Although living in the occupied town of Copenhagen, Denmark, would be hard, now they had to try to escape with their Jewish friends.  This story is very suspenseful. After the first chapter the book starts to take off into an exciting adventure. As the storyline progresses, we meet some very interesting characters.

Once the law has been passed by the Germans, the Rosens leave town with Peter Neilsen (a part of the Danish resistant), and leave their daughter Ellen with the Johansens.  It was like a sleepover to the girls–until the Germans came and searched the Johansens’ apartment. Luckily Mr. Johansen had pictures of his deceased daughter, Lise, when she had black hair. When the Germans questioned why Ellen (the Jew pretending to be the Johansen’s daughter) had black hair, Mr. Johansen acted as though she were his daughter, Lise. After the Germans left, Mrs. Johansen decided that it was too dangerous for the girls to go to school, so they left town to visit Annemarie’s Uncle Henrik, the fisherman in Gilleleje. Nearing their destination, they passed the Klampenborg station, where German soldiers boarded the train. While on the train ride, Kirsti, who almost gave away that Ellen was Jewish to the German soldiers, talked on about her shoes.  After Mrs. Johansen told the soldiers their business of seeing her brother, the soldiers were on their way. Finally, they reached Gilleleje. Walking to  Henrik’s house, they were astonished by the beauty of the wonderful water and the wildflowers. As soon as they got there they were told by Uncle Henrik that there has been a death in the family; Annemarie’s great Aunt Bertie had died. Annemarie soon found out that there really was no Aunt Bertie. The funeral was an excuse for the escaping Jews to gather at the house. After people came, the German soldiers arrived. They questioned about the coffin and left. After that Mr. and Mrs. Rosen were reunited with their daughter, Ellen. Quickly Peter slipped Mr. Rosen a package to take to Henrik and took the first few people to his boat and hid them there. When it was Mrs. Johansen’s turn to take the Rosens to the boat, Mr. Rosen slipped on the steps and unknowingly dropped the package. Ellen, who had given Annemarie a quick hug and left, was sad and wondering if she would ever find her friend again. The next morning Annemarie noticed her mother on the ground in front of the house. Her mother had broken her ankle, and there, next to her mother, Annemarie found the package that Peter had given to Mr. Rosen. Annemarie got a basket, put the package at the bottom, and put a napkin and some food over it. Then she ran toward Henrik’s boat with his “lunch.” Running to the boat, she met up with German soldiers and their dogs. The Germans took the food and ruined it. Then they discovered the hidden package and opened it! There was only a hankerchief. What could it mean? The dogs smelled it and were suddenly not interested. The soldiers left. Annemarie delivered the packet. The Jews had been saved!

Reading this suspenseful story, one can’t wait to find out what happens next. The best thing about this book is that Annemarie and her family amazingly find ways to outsmart the Germans. Although the Germans came to the apartment, the Johansens outsmarted them with the pictures which had been taken out of the scrap book. After that, the Germans were outsmarted with the fake funeral. Would you have been able to do what Annemarie had done? The Resistance saved over seven thousand Jews. Flawlessly Lois Lowery makes the characters as if they were real. Number the Stars is a real masterpiece!

A Cinematic Treat by Kira Ripley, age 15

Valkyrie was produced by United Artists and released to theaters on Christmas day 2008.  Staring Tom Cruise, Valkyrie was based upon an actual assassination plot that unfurled during the height of WWII. Rated PG-13, this movie was directed by Bryan Singer and based on the screenplay written by Christopher McQuarrie and Nathan Alexander. On it’s opening weekend, Valkryie earned $21,027,007. But does that make it worth seeing?

Valkyrie follows the dramatic story of Claus Von Stauffenberg, a colonel in the German army during WWII. Unhappy with how Hitler is controlling Germany, Colonel Stauffenberg and several co-conspirators conclude they must take over Germany. Their plan is to assassinate Hitler. Cunningly, using Hitler’s own plan for succession, which is called Operation Valkyrie, the conspirators will take over Germany. Operation Valkyrie was designed to allow the Nazi’s to stay in power if Hitler was ever assassinated. However, with a few modifications by Stauffenberg and his co-conspirators, Operation Valkyrie allows them to take over Germany, using Hitler’s own troops. In order to assassinate Hitler, Colonel Stauffenberg conspires to blow him up using a time bomb.

On July 20, 1944, everything is prepared and Colonel Stauffenberg is to attend a meeting with Hitler, where he will place the time bomb. When Stuaffenberg arrives at the designated meeting place, he begins preparing the bomb, which he shrewdly conceals in a briefcase. While in the meeting, Stauffenberg receives a call from his co-conspirators. Quickly, Stauffenberg exits the room, leaving the bomb in the briefcase inside the bunker with Hitler. As soon as he exits the humid bunker, in which the meeting was held, the bomb explodes.

After having detonated the bomb, Stauffenberg flies back to Berlin, believing Hitler is dead. Back in Berlin, the coconspirators are to start Operation Valkryie, but because they didn’t receive confirmation that Hitler was dead, Operation Valkyrie didn’t commence right away. When Colonel Stauffenberg arrives three hours later, he finds that Operation Valkyrie has just begun, rather than three hours earlier when it should have. Undaunted, Colonel Stauffenberg proceeds with his plan, despite the delay. Now the conspirators must make up for lost time, but even the best of laid plans sometimes go awry.

Anyone who has ever studied World War II history in depth will know the outcome of the movie. Even still, Valkyrie manages to keep viewers on the edge of their seats throughout the duration of the film. The movie also keeps the viewer guessing what will happen next. The characters in this movie are very compelling, allowing viewers’ to connect to the characters. The acting was phenomenal, really bringing the characters to life. For instance, when a co-conspirator didn’t fulfill his part in the plan, the audience sympathizes with the man’s actions, even if they don’t agree with them. Additionally, the movie is very historically accurate. Valkyrie’s gripping ending, leaves the audience craving for more, and is unforgettable. However, this movie does contain many intense scenes, and is not recommended for younger children. Over all, Valkyrie was a rare cinematic treat for older teens and adults who enjoy action or war films, crave suspense movies, or adore history.

An Analysis of All Quiet on the Western Front by Andrew Josefchak, Age 13

In All Quiet on the Western Front, Erich Maria Remarque portrays the horrors of war. Remarque himself fought in World War I, which may be why he presents war as being so horrifying. He effectively depicts these horrors through the everyday experiences of German soldiers during World War I, and especially how the main character, Paul, has been dehumanized by war. Paul remembers what he was like before the war, but he tries not to think about it because he knows he can never be that person again. He cannot relate to a typical way of life.

Before the war, Paul was a normal, somewhat scholarly person. He spent all his money on books. He did not think of much but school and he did not know what he would do with himself after he finished high school. As the war progresses, some of the older men talk about their lives at home, and what they will do after the war. However, Paul cannot relate, as he has no life besides school and war. He is no longer interested in learning, and he comments several times throughout the book that all the things that he used to so dearly love are pointless to him now. At one point in the book, Paul and his friends from school mock the things they used to think were so important, such as “How many children has Charles the Bald?” (84). He thinks about how the only things that matter to him now are how to listen for different kinds of shells, how to find cover, and how to stay sane during an artillery bombardment.

Paul was very carefree and innocent before he went to war. After returning from the front, Paul gets sentry duty, which gives him time to stand in the darkness and reminisce about his childhood:

“Between the meadows behind our town there stands a line of old poplars by a stream. They were visible from a great distance, and although they grew on one bank only, we called them the poplar avenue. Even as children we had a great love for them, they drew us vaguely thither, we played truant the whole day by them and listened to their rustling. We sat beneath them on the bank of the stream and let our feet hang in the bright, swift waters. The pure fragrance of the water and the melody of the wind in the poplars held our fancies. We loved them dearly, and the image of those days still makes my heart pause in its beating.” (120).

Instead of being cheered by this memory, Paul is saddened. Even though the stand of poplars is still there, he cannot enjoy it as he used to.

When Paul goes home on leave, he sits in his room and attempts to read his old schoolbooks and classical literature that he has collected. However, he cannot remember why he thought them to be important. He tries not to think about it, because he knows nothing that he can do will make him enjoy learning again. Paul reflects:

“The backs of the books stand in rows. I know them all still, I remember arranging them order. I implore them with my eyes: Speak to me–take me up–take me, Life of my Youth-you who are care-free, beautiful-receive me again-

I wait, I wait.

Images float through my mind, but they do not grip me, they are mere shadows and memories.

Nothing-nothing-

My disquietude grows.

A terrible feeling of foreignness suddenly rises up in me. I cannot find my way back, I am shut out though I entreat earnestly and put forth all my strength.

Nothing stirs: listless and wretched, like a condemned man, I sit there and the past withdraws itself. And at the same time I fear to importune it too much, because I do not know what might happen then. I am a soldier, I must cling to that.” (172-173).

He also cannot relate to anyone he used to know, including his family. His father wants Paul to dress in his uniform, so he can show off “his soldier,” and does not understand why Paul refuses. His father also wants to hear stories about the front, but Paul refuses to tell him any: “I realize he does not know that a man cannot talk of such things; I would do it willingly, but it is too dangerous for me to put these things into words. I am afraid they might then become gigantic and I be no longer able to master them. What would become of us if everything that that happens out there were quite clear to us?” (165). Paul never truly thinks about what happens at the front. He never has to worry about it, because he is killed before he gets a chance to.

Remarque further illustrates how Paul has been hardened by war when Paul states

“Parting with my friend Albert Kropp was very hard. But one gets used to that sort of thing in the army.” (269). Paul has gotten used to losing friends. Every single one of his friends is killed over the course of the war, and then Paul is killed as well. The only death that truly hurts him is the death of Katczinsky, his best friend, who is portrayed throughout the book as being sort of “untouchable.” Katczinsky is Paul’s best friend, even though he is much older than Paul at 40. He is also somewhat of a father figure for Paul and his friends. He has a strange knack for finding food, and even finds four boxes of lobsters at one point. It seems as though nothing bad could ever happen to him, but in the end he is hit in the leg, and as Paul carries him to the infirmary, Kat is killed by a splinter from a stray shell.

Many books, movies, and games portray war as being heroic; however, All Quiet on the Western Front shows war as a terrible thing, capable of turning men into animals in seconds. It shows how the main character, Paul, is turned from a young, innocent schoolboy into an emotionally-numb soldier. To make the ending even more affecting, Paul himself is killed on such a quiet day that the entirety of the military report is “All quiet on the Western Front.” Perhaps Remarque ends the book this way because he wishes he had been killed as well.

The Thrill of Legend by Jeth Floyd

Based on Richard Matheson’s book of the same name, I Am Legend appeared on the silver screen December of 2007. However, the story has been adapted to the screen two other times. Matheson is famous for authoring stories of the Sci-Fi and Horror genres, while also co-directing other screen adaptations and writing episodes of The Twilight Zone. Because of Matheson’s book, much of Sci-Fi and Horror in the media has been thoroughly and permanently influenced. This film version of his novel was directed by Francis Lawrence, normally a music-video director, and stars Will Smith.

During a live interview, a scientist in present-day Manhattan, New York shares her method of curing cancer with a news anchor. She explains the measles, genetically reprogrammed, have completely eradicated and removed the cancerous tissue in all one thousand nine human test subjects, therefore confidently and resolutely confirming that she has indeed cured cancer. Jumping ahead three years, the Big Apple lays in ruins deserted, decrepit, and destroyed. Robert Neville, a lieutenant-colonel and scientist, seems to be the only person alive. He is not alone. After three years at “ground zero” trying to stop what became of the enhanced measles—known as the KV virus—he discovers a possible, promising solution.

Because of the virus, what is left of the human race has become a violent mass of biting, screaming monsters. After various attempts and numerous failed trails, Robert Neville refuses to give up his search for a potential antidote.  As he tries to perfect the cure, the diseased people called “Dark Seekers”—so named for their inability to survive ultra violate light—wish to avenge the loss of a member Robert had taken to his basement for testing. It’s a race against time. Will Robert Neville find a way to stop the disease and cure its victims while also trying to stay alive? Or will he succumb to the doom that awaits him at the pale, clawed hands of the Dark Seekers?

When Robert seeks his own revenge for the death of his canine companion, Sam, he is overwhelmed by the Dark Seekers and nearly killed. Fading in and out of consciousness, Robert attempts to tell a strange, unfamiliar voice where he lives before blacking out completely. After talking with Anna—the woman who saved him from his suicide attempt—Robert learns that she and a young boy, Ethan, are traveling to a supposed survivor colony in Vermont. Robert hears roaring and hissing in the distance as he tries to convince Anna that all other human life is either gone or diseased. The Dark Seekers followed them. Futilely Robert tries to drive them away from his home, but the Dark Seekers are bent on retribution. Down in the basement, Robert, Anna, and Ethan find that the antidote is working in the sedated patient. After stashing Anna and Ethan in a secret closet and giving them a sample saying, “The cure is in the blood,” Robert heroically and unwaveringly sacrifices himself to keep his new friends and the cure safe until morning. When Anna and Ethan arrive in Vermont, they find the survivors’ colony and humanity is saved by the endeavors of Robert Neville: scientist, hero, legend.

This Sci-Fi thriller has wonderful graphics with an equally stunning plot and superb acting. Though some might think the “shaken camera syndrome” seems sloppy or unprofessional, it gives this film a certain documentary flavor that allows viewers to feel closer to the action. Not surprisingly, Will Smith gives a magnificent performance which, coupled with life-like monsters and animals, adds dramatic reality. But that’s not the best part. Among the tension and the monsters, I Am Legend not only refrains from the use of adult themes and language, but also incorporates Christian themes such as faith and destiny. For example, when Anna tells Robert that God has assured her of the colony’s existence, she explains to him that God has a plan, all we have to do is listen. I Am Legend is the perfect film for those who favor thrills and excitement without the distraction of profanity.

A Child Called It by Kari Landis

Dear Mr. Pelzer,

I have read your book, A Child Called “It”, twice now and both times it has brought me to tears.  It kept me very interested and yet sometimes I had to force myself to read because of how horrible it was.  A child Called “It” has opened my eyes to the area of child abuse, made me think harder about life, and challenged me.

Reading it the second time forced me to think more about what was happening in the book.  As I read, I realized how God does work in mysterious ways and how we do not see the whole picture but He does.  It amazed me the way you kept on saying that you gave up on God or you did not believe He was real and yet you kept on praying.  He was your only hope and the only one you could talk to.  In the end, it all worked out for good and that showed me that if we hold on and keep on hoping and praying God is going to bring us through whatever we are going through.  God was there with you, keeping you from jumping off the side of the ship and healing your wounds, and through all of it you gained a better appreciation of life.  It was all part of God’s plan.  If you had not gone through all of the abuse and survived you most likely would not have been the person you are today.  You would not have made such a big difference in the lives of abused children.  I realized that we have to be thankful for the good and bad in our lives because it really shapes who we become.

Another thing I learned from reading your book was that we can not look to humans, money, power, or whatever else to save us.  You always looked to your Dad as your savior even though he let you down so many times.  In the end he deserted you and the family.  This goes to show how we are all sinful and we can not rely on others for protection because all of us make mistakes. Our only true source of protection comes from God.

The biggest way it impacted me was it really inspired me to be an elementary teacher.  Reading it sparked a flame in me.  I have always loved children and reading the book broke my heart.  I want to be a teacher that shows love and respect to each child as and individual.  You wrote about the incident with the substitute teacher, “The substitute teacher had been so nice to me.  She treated me like a real person not like some piece of filth lying in the gutter.”  Wow, our actions and words can make such a difference!  That is the type of teacher I would like to be.  While reading the book, I realized how much I want to make a difference in people’s lives, especially children’s lives.  I want to be the one to give a hug to a hurting, lonely, and unloved child, like you had been.

A Child Called “It” was such an encouraging book to read.  I got so much out of it.  I learned that we need to trust and rely on God to bring us through each situation.  He is the only one that will save us.  Sometimes we do not understand His plan but we just have to trust Him.  But most importantly I realized how badly I want to make a difference in children’s lives.  Thank you for writing this book.  I am sure it was a long and hard process but I believe God has used it to encourage many people just like it encouraged me.

Sincerely,

Kari Landis

Flat Stanley by Catherine Volz

The book, Flat Stanley, is a fiction book that has chapters. The author, who is Jeff Brown, wrote this book. When this book was published in 1964, Scholastic, Inc. was the company who published it.

In an average size city, Flat Stanley lives with his parents, who are Mr. and Mrs. Lambchop. Regardless of what happens, they are happy and calm. Arthur, who is Stanley’s younger brother, is helpful, but is jealous of Stanley’s fame at times. Living in an apartment, Stanley is happy. Although summer is hot, Stanley enjoys it.

While Stanley was asleep, a bulletin board fell on him. When he woke up, he found himself flat. In the book, Stanley had many adventures including like catching the sneak thieves. Arthur has been nice to Stanley, but sometimes he gets a little jealous because Stanley gets the attention.

Gratefully, Flat Stanley catches the sneak thieves, which makes him a hero. Far away, people started to laugh at him and he did not like that. It is important to do kind deeds.

I like Flat Stanley because he is flat. Stanley had a great time at my house because he got cold and he went on a trip when my Dad went to Omaha. He had fun!